What to Look For When Hiring a Small Business Coach

All products and services featured on this site are independently selected by our authors and editors. If you buy something through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

minute/s remaining

Most small business owners consider hiring a coach at some point in their journey. According to a former bank director and small business owner, here is what to look for when hiring a small business coach.

Companies Don't Hire a Business Coach or Board Because They Like Giving Away Cash

If you've been on the fence about reaching out for help, consider the fact that there are ZERO public companies without a board of directors. It's actually a legal requirement for a corporation to elect a board. No one creates a large company without some help.

A CPA put it this way:

“My coach helped me double my income this year! Coaches get bashed all the time, and it's not fair. Almost all of my clients who make more than 300K HAVE a coach- especially the ones that are really young!”

An Eye-Opening Experience

The first time I sat on a Board of Directors, it was eye-opening. There were fifteen of us in the room, and no one was working for peanuts.

The company didn't hire us because they liked handing out wads of cash. No, they invested in that because they knew that having external accountability and ideas would earn them far more than what they spent.

A top-notch business coach is like having a mini-board at a fraction of a full board cost. That's why coaches are normally used for small businesses that can't afford to shell out $50k a month for a single board meeting.

Companies don't just give money away
Companies don't give away wads of cash to business coaches or board members to be charitable

Coaching Should Go Beyond Getting More Business

Most business coaches can help you get more business. A good coach will also know the rules and help set your business up with a firm foundation. The best ones will help you refine your offerings and processes to improve your bottom line and create a steady revenue stream.

You Should Have Clear Action Items From Each Coaching Session

Have you ever left a meeting wondering what the next step is? Good coaches will leave no uncertainty about that next step. You should have clear ACTION items to be completed before the next call.

Clear action items - your business coach should assign clear action items
You and your business coach should agree upon clear action items during each session

Your Business Coach Should Help You Refine Your Processes

My sales process for business coaching is crystal clear. My clients visit my coaching page. There is ONE action for them to take, repeated in various ways. Sign up to move to the next step. The next step of the sales process is clear as well, and most people who take that first step end up becoming clients.

A good business coach should help you refine your own processes so they are clear. Clear processes make it so that your business can scale because you can automate it or train other people once you have those nailed down.

Mapping out business processes to maximize profitability
Your business coach should be able to help you map out your processes

Your Coach Should Help You Lay the Foundation

I was visiting with a small business owner who owns a moving business the other day. We were talking about expanding his business beyond him, and an analogy came to me. Growing a business without a firm foundation is like stacking a heavy dresser on top of a wobbly glass end table in a moving truck.

“Growing a business without a firm foundation is like stacking a heavy dresser on top of a wobbly glass end table in a moving truck.”

If I dumped an extra 5,000 orders on you tomorrow, would you be able to handle that? A properly set up business should be able to expand to accommodate new business easily. Don't start with a flimsy glass table as your foundation, or your business is going to shatter into a million pieces when you add something heavy.

Glass table - illustration of business failure due to fast growth without a proper foundation
Don't use a flimsy glass table as the foundation for your business

Your Business Coach Should Encourage You to Cover Your Assets

Things are relatively simple when it's just you, but following the rules gets more critical and complex as you grow and add people. That's where a good business coach can help. I've seen multi-millionaires go bankrupt virtually overnight because their business was built like a house of cards, and when the wind blew, all came tumbling down.

Your coach should help you follow the rules and make sure you have things like a proper LLC operating agreement, subcontractor agreements, policy manual, and insurance to cover yourself in the event of a problem.

Working in your business
What happens if he breaks his back while working for you?

Business coaches are not lawyers. On the other hand, your coach should speak intelligently about at least some legal and liability concerns.

Run if Your Coach Tells You Not to Worry About the IRS

I've seen far too many small business owners go pale as they find out that they owe many thousands in back taxes plus fines. You cannot continue to operate a growing business out of your household checking account or ignore the regulations without eventually facing the consequences.

If you don't think the IRS is watching, think again. If your business coach is advising you to ignore regulations, run.

Audits aren't fun. Do it right from the beginning.

Regulation Violations are Expensive

I remember asking during one board meeting the consequences of ignoring a violation cited on an audit report. It required us to hire additional people to stay in compliance, which meant costs would add up quickly. The answer was approximately $2.3 million every year. We voted unanimously to hire the people necessary to satisfy the regulation.

A business coach isn't your accountant or attorney, but they should help get your business set up with a solid foundation so you can grow.

A Good Business Coach Capable of Building Their Own Business Isn't Cheap

Lodestone Global survey that evaluated 331 companies reported that the average board of director member has a total annual compensation of about $36,000.

Though a board of directors' pay pales compared to that of CEOs, compensation for board service can inch into the half-million-dollar range—and in a few cases, much higher. Below is a list of the highest-paid boards of directors at large-cap companies according to Equilar data.

The Best Aren't Cheap

Company NameAnnual Director Retainer
Regeneron Pharmaceuticals$2,074,085
The Goldman Sachs Group$575,000
Celgene Corporation$524,871
Reynolds American$496,480
Valeant Pharmaceuticals International$475,000
Allergan PLC$450,000
Everest Re Group, Ltd.$447,030

You want to hire someone who has actually built a business and managed people, not someone with only second-hand knowledge. A person like that isn't likely to get out of their cozy bed for $100.

A Small Business Coach Isn't the Same as a Board Member

Most reputable small business coaches won't charge as much as a director on a board because they don't have the same responsibilities.

A formal board of directors has legal responsibilities and voting rights on what happens in an organization. They can even fire the CEO if necessary. Going to jail, while unlikely, is a possibility if they mess up.

With a coach, you are in charge and make the final decisions. There is little to no risk to your coach other than their reputation, which means they normally don't demand the same level of compensation that high-powered board members do.

As a small business coach, I'm not going to jail if you fail to follow some regulations.

Industry-Specific Knowledge is Overrated

When I was hired to be a bank director, I had never worked in the industry. That's the reason they hired me; they wanted fresh ideas from a successful small business owner. They didn't need another banker.

I have worked with many businesses across a wide variety of industries. Management problems are often the same because people are the same. Sales are sales, although there are differences between retail and high ticket sales. Service is service, again with minor differences between industries.

Hiring someone outside your industry can bring in fresh ideas. Just make sure they have run a successful business personally and managed people.

Baby standing in front of a fancy car
Make sure your business coach has real-world experience running a company and managing people and isn't just good with marketing.

Hire a Business Coach Who Has Run an Actual Business

TLDR: When looking for a small business coach, make sure they have run a business, and managed people. Ensure they know how to lay the proper foundation so you can grow and aren't simply pushing lead generation. Expect to pay well and ask more questions if they are really cheap; this is one area you usually get what you pay for.

What to Look For When Hiring a Small Business Coach

About the Author 

Don Smith

Former bank director who enjoys helping people master their finances. Father of five, founder of The Personal Growth Channel, and business owner.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Work-life balance, that’s the catchphrase these days, right? I’m sure you’ve heard phrases like “Never get so busy making a living that you forget to make a life.” Jack Welch, the former CEO of GE, said “There is no such thing as work-life balance. There are work-life choices, and you make them, and they have

Finding work life balance: How I worked nearly 60 hours this week and still spent quality time with family and friends.

The boss walked into the meeting room, and the atmosphere suddenly turned chilly. No one wanted to be here because everyone knew this guy had no business being the leader. We’ve all been there, and we’ve all also heard the mantra over and over that we need to step up and lead. In general, that’s

When You Should NOT Be The Leader